Has Academia Ruined Literary Criticism?

Norge Nyheter Nyheter

Has Academia Ruined Literary Criticism?
Norge Siste Nytt,Norge Overskrifter
  • 📰 NewYorker
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 68 sec. here
  • 3 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 30%
  • Publisher: 67%

Since the 1960s, the proportion of students pursuing degrees in English has dropped by more than half. Is the academy to blame?

Of the character sketches that the English satirist Samuel Butler wrote in the mid-seventeenth century—among them “A Degenerate Noble,” “A Huffing Courtier,” “A Small Poet,” and “A Romance Writer”—the most recognizable today is “A Modern Critic.” He is a contemptible creature: a tyrant, a pedant, a crackpot, and a snob; “a very ungentle Reader”; “a Corrector of the Press gratis”; “ain the Commonwealth of letters”; “a Mountebank, that is always quacking of the infirm and diseased Parts of Books.

Professionalization, he argues, secured intellectual autonomy for criticism’s practitioners. They could produce knowledge about literature in a manner intelligible chiefly to others producing the same kind of knowledge—a project that became both increasingly specialized and increasingly justified by political concerns, such as race, gender, equality, and the environment.

“Professing Criticism” proceeds on the basis that, in order to decipher the present and to prepare for the future, one must first turn to the past. “The study of literature—in the premodern sense of any writing that has been preserved or valued—is very old, the oldest kind of organized study in Western history, excepting only rhetoric,” Guillory writes. But a distinct genre of writing called “criticism” first appeared in the late seventeenth century.

Yet, at the turn of the twentieth century, something strange happened, something that, by 1925, led Woolf to look around and lament the sudden absence of greatness. “Reviewers we have but no critic; a million competent and incorruptible policemen but no judge. Men of taste and learning and ability are for ever lecturing the young,” she wrote. “But the too frequent result of their able and industrious pens is a desiccation of the living tissues of literature into a network of little bones.

Vi har oppsummert denne nyheten slik at du kan lese den raskt. Er du interessert i nyhetene kan du lese hele teksten her. Les mer:

NewYorker /  🏆 90. in US

Norge Siste Nytt, Norge Overskrifter

Similar News:Du kan også lese nyheter som ligner på denne som vi har samlet inn fra andre nyhetskilder.

Pamela Anderson says stolen sex tape 'ruined' relationship with ex Tommy Lee: 'Our hell began'Pamela Anderson says stolen sex tape 'ruined' relationship with ex Tommy Lee: 'Our hell began'Former 'Baywatch' star Pamela Anderson revealed her tumultuous relationship with rock star Tommy Lee in her all-encompassing memoir, 'Love, Pamela.' The 55-year-old also admitted that her relationship with Lee may have been the only time she was ever 'truly in love.'
Les mer »

My Hero Academia Reveals Shigaraki's Dark New DilemmaMy Hero Academia Reveals Shigaraki's Dark New DilemmaThe Paranormal Liberation War might be over in the sixth season of My Hero Academia's anime [...]
Les mer »

My Hero Academia, Please Give Us a Vigilante Deku MovieMy Hero Academia, Please Give Us a Vigilante Deku MovieMy Hero Academia is moving into the second half of season six, and that means things are about to [...]
Les mer »

My Hero Academia Season 6 Shares Shoto's Goal for DabiMy Hero Academia Season 6 Shares Shoto's Goal for DabiThe Paranormal Liberation War might have come to an end in season six of My Hero Academia, but [...]
Les mer »

I ruined my family’s finances by withdrawing from my 401(k) to buy a house – I regret itI ruined my family’s finances by withdrawing from my 401(k) to buy a house – I regret itHave a question about your own retirement savings? Email us at HelpMeRetiremarketwatch.com
Les mer »

Patricia Highsmith’s Forbidden LovePatricia Highsmith’s Forbidden LoveOn Patricia Highsmith’s birthday, revisit Margaret Talbot on the passions behind Highsmith’s uniquely romantic novel “The Price of Salt.”
Les mer »



Render Time: 2025-03-12 13:23:34